Desserts in Englewood

Fruit-flavored ice cream anchors desserts at Beachcomber Trading Post Restaurant in Englewood, FL, with pickup available.

Order online

Desserts to Try

Soft Serve Ice Cream

Soft-serve ice cream in vanilla, pineapple, or pineapple-vanilla twist.

Very Vanilla Soft Serve$4.00Very vanilla soft serve in a small serving, selected from the available flavor options.
Pineapple Paradise Soft Serve$4.00Pineapple Paradise soft serve in a small serving, selected from the available flavor options.
Pineapple Twist Soft Serve$4.00Pineapple Twist soft serve in a small serving, combining pineapple and vanilla soft serve.

“Really can’t say enough great things about this place. Family owned, beautiful setting, great management. You instantly feel like you’re on vacation in the tropics. We ate lunch, went for a bike ride, and came back for dessert - worth a trip here just for the soft-serve pineapple / vanilla ice cream on a sunny Florida day!”

“We had the pineapple vanilla soft serve Bacardi dark rum drink and it was delish. I had the blackened grouper sandwich on Cuban bread with a side salad and my friend had the philly cheesecake with fries. The grouper was real grouper and the bread amazing. The fries hot and crispy. We loved it and will go back. The atmosphere was really nice and the playlist of jimmy buffet and the like was perfect. Our first visit and we will go back”

Key Lime Pie

$8.00

Tangy lime custard baked in a crumb crust.

“Tried beachcomber last night for dinner and it was 10/10! By far the best grouper sandwich available on the key. The peel and eat shrimp was also amazing. Delicious key lime pie too!”

Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream

$8.00

Vanilla soft serve layered with strawberry puree and graham crumbs.

“We had such a great experience here! The drinks were spot on — refreshing and perfectly made. The highlight, though, was the strawberry shortcake dessert… absolutely incredible! Light, fresh, and so delicious — truly the best place we went in Englewood! Highly recommend!”

Brownie

$5.00

A baked chocolate square with a rich cocoa flavor.

Welcome to Beachcomber Trading Post Restaurant

Desserts at Beachcomber Trading Post Restaurant range from frozen sweets to pie and brownies. The ice cream choices include fruit flavors, while pie and brownies offer alternatives to a frozen dessert.

Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream features vanilla soft serve layered with strawberry puree and graham cracker crumbs. For a dessert beyond ice cream, you can order Key Lime Pie or Brownie.

Visit us in Englewood, FL for dine-in, or order pickup or delivery. Soft Serve Ice Cream comes in vanilla, pineapple or a twist of both, with a Family Size Togo (pint) option for a larger serving.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular desserts options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream — Vanilla soft serve is layered with strawberry puree and graham cracker crumbs for a strawberry-shortcake-inspired frozen dessert.
Key Lime Pie — This classic pie features a tart, creamy lime filling set in a crumb crust for a sliceable dessert.
Soft Serve Ice Cream — Choose vanilla, pineapple, or a pineapple-vanilla twist, then select small, large, or pint-size family takeout.
Brownie — This classic brownie is a baked chocolate square, offering a compact dessert with a cocoa-forward flavor.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for desserts throughout the Englewood area. Order your desserts online for convenient pickup or delivery.